Post
by Legacy User » Tue Sep 09, 2014 2:33 pm
If you read the whole article and all of the players quotes and all of Troy's quotes I think it's totally legitimate to toss in discussion of the punishment, and the NFL's piss-poor handling of the matter.
So I will get this off my chest- the video speaks for itself. There is no way to argue that what Ray Rice does on that video is anything remotely acceptable for any reason whatsoever. I'm not defending Ray Rice's actions there, and I don't think anyone on the Steelers is, either, by not commenting. They really don't need to say anything the man didn't say for himself through his own actions.
That said, I think you really have to address two things with that- (1) how severe a transgression was this, and (2) what, if anything mitigates it?
As to (1)- in the scope of world conduct it's about 6 or a 7 on a 10 point scale where 10 is the worst you can be. Bear in mind that half a world away there are thousands of people who actively desire to kill every American they can, who also feel that acceptable conduct towards women is raping them to ensure their souls are damned to hell, then selling them as slaves.... This doesn't make Ray Rice's woman-beating acceptable, but he's not Rae Carruth, either (yet).
As to (2)- there is just a whole bunch of shit we don't know. What is his prior history? What do any professionals think? What's his behavior been like since? Was he remorseful? These things can be argued, but in terms of what Roger Goodell and the Ravens are doing- it's apparently irrelevant because TMZ published something they most certainly knew existed all along.
And that's where I think the players are saying "hey, we didn't vote for this asshole" in the context of any broader discourse about Ray Rice. From their perspective (and it also rubs me the wrong way to a certain degree), Goodell is taking two bites of the apple- and he's doing it because TMZ went and made a bad situation even worse for not only Ray Rice (and for a second let's just say "fuck him") AND the victim. I can't imagine she really wants video of her ass getting knocked out by a man she at one point loved (and maybe still does) all over the airwaves. Maybe she does... I doubt it.
How is what Ray Rice did any different from McDonald, or here's another name that hasn't been brought up yet on this board- Greg Hardy? It's not like the police report wasn't made available to the NFL. They totally fucking knew the video was out there and chose not to ask for it, or consider it. They were willing participants in giving Ray Rice a 2nd chance. Oh, but now, now that TMZ has thrown something up there, they've changed their tune. BTW- Greg Hardy and MacDonald played last Sunday.
The NFL and the Ravens are legally entitled to do whatever the fuck they want. That doesn't mean they've chosen to be equitable or that they treated Ray Rice fairly or proportionately. In all likelihood, Hardy and MacDonald will, at worst, get 6 game suspensions as first offenders simply because no one caught them on tape. And that's fucked up.