W&M_Steeler wrote: ↑Wed Sep 04, 2024 9:08 pm
K_C_ wrote: ↑Wed Sep 04, 2024 8:16 pm
When's the last time the Steelers had a defensive lineman with 3 seasons of 10 or more sacks? (Heyward also had 12 sacks in 2017.)
That's nice- how many sacks did Cam have in the playoffs in 2017? How many tackles? (0 and 1, respectively?). People used to hate Bettis for being a playoff choker, but Cam makes Bettis look like a post-season stud.
No one is arguing that Cam sucks. My position is that he's already proven incapable of helping the team to get to the next level, so why spend tens of millions on a guy who's likely past his prime? I'd rather move on and try to build anew. But with the Tomlin extension and the Cam extension, it's signaling same old, same old. Cam having a good regular season in 2024 will help in the quest for securing NHALS, though.
Heyward's been awful in the playoffs.
We also very likely never make the playoffs without Heyward.
As for your "why are we spending tens of millions on a guy who's likely past his prime", I have 2 responses. First you rightfully used the word "likely." You know as well as I do that if Heyward can avoid injuries, he's going to be a force. Yep, even at his current age. Dude sucked last year. I won't deny that but after returning from injury, lots of guys suck returning from injuries, especially when they're trying to play while still injured.
Also, this is literally a ONE YEAR PROVE IT DEAL Heyward is on. What else do you want Rooney to do with that 16 million? Bank it? He might as well spend it on Cam and if he sucks, the guy will retire. If he has a bounce back year and dominates, then we'll all be hoping like a motherfucker he returns next season.
This is absolutely the right move by the Steelers.
Lastly, you making the comment that if Cam has a good season that secures the NHALS. You DO know the Steelers aren't going to tank this year, right? Under no circumstances are they going look to lose games. While we all hate the NHALS, I'd much rather have that than watch a team outright trying to lose. That isn't going to happen. If they do go 4-13, they're going to do it the old fashioned way. By sucking even though everybody is trying 100% to win.
"...It's very difficult to keep the line between the past and the present... Do you know what I mean...?"
Edith 'Little Edie' Bouvier Beale